Skip to main content

INFLUENCE AT WORK - INFLUENCE AT WORK- Official Site

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on LinkedInFollow Us on YouTube
Professors, Get your copy of Pre-Suasion
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Robert Cialdini, PhD
      • Dr. Cialdini’s Biography
      • Dr. Cialdini’s Books and Publications
      • Keynotes
      • Curriculum Vitae
      • Testimonials
        • Financial Services
        • General
        • Pharmaceutical/Healthcare
        • Technology
        • International Business
        • Leadership & Management
        • Sales & Marketing
      • Downloadable Photos
    • CMCT Trainers
    • Executive Leadership
      • Robert Cialdini, PhD
      • Gregory Neidert, PhD
      • Bobette Gorden
    • INFLUENCE AT WORK Staff
    • FAQs
    • Principles of Persuasion by Dr. Robert Cialdini
    • INFLUENCE AT WORK Company Information
      • Consulting
  • Speaking
    • Robert Cialdini, PhD
      • Dr. Cialdini’s Biography
      • Dr. Cialdini’s Books and Publications
      • Keynotes
      • Curriculum Vitae
      • Videos
      • Testimonials
        • Financial Services
        • General
        • Pharmaceutical/Healthcare
        • Technology
        • International Business
        • Leadership & Management
        • Sales & Marketing
      • Downloadable Photos
    • CMCT Speakers
    • Testimonials
  • Training
    • CMCT Certification
    • Certified Trainers
    • CMCT Testimonials
    • Exclusive CMCT Login
    • Test Your IQ (Influence Quotient)
    • CMCT Readiness Quiz
  • POP® Workshops
    • Corporate/In-House Customized Principles of Persuasion (POP) Workshop
      • Workshop Materials
      • Clients
      • Workshop Testimonials
      • Contact
      • Fees and Details
      • Past POP Photos
    • Public POP Workshop
      • Workshop Overview
      • Waitlist Request
      • Clients
      • What You Will Learn
      • Hotel Information
      • POP Workshop® Testimonials
      • Contact
      • Past POP Photos
  • Pre-Suasion®
    • Moment Maker™ Workshop
    • Pre-Suasion Training Early Notification
    • Corporate/In-House Training
    • Pre-Suasion Keynotes by Dr. Cialdini
    • Course Adoptions
  • Media
    • Articles and Case Studies
    • Downloadable Photos
    • Videos
    • Audio Interviews
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
    • Subscribe to IIR Blog
Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on Google+Follow Us on TwitterFollow Us on YouTube

How You Can Sabotage Your Own Good Intentions

Tweet

By Steve Martin, CMCT

How You Can Sabotage Your Own Good IntentionsYou do your best to recycle whenever you can, right? Maybe the company you work for has a pro-environmental policy that encourages staff to use less paper and to recycle as much as possible of that which is used. It certainly wouldn’t be alone. Increasing numbers of organizations, communities too, are recognizing the benefits of recycling as a way to conserve energy and natural resources and many will have policies and strategies in place to encourage it.

But could certain strategies designed to persuade people to recycle actually be counterproductive leading to an increase rather than a decrease in the use of resources? A new study suggests that, at least in certain conditions, they could. It turns out that the insights gleaned from this study don’t just have implications for your office environmental policy.

They may also have implications for your wider change initiatives too.

Influence rarely occurs in a vacuum and one possible implication of focusing attention on a single specific behavior is that it might lead to unintended, even counterproductive behaviors down the line. Behavioral scientists call this ‘licensing’ or a ‘negative spillover’ and we can probably all think of examples from our personal lives. Spending an extra ten minutes on the treadmill so that we feel a little fitter might also convince us that we have earned the right to that tasty muffin to accompany our morning coffee. Selecting the healthy salad at lunch might ‘buy’ us the right to a dessert, or a ride on the elevator instead of the stairs when returning to our desk.

How You Can Sabotage Your Own Good IntentionsJesse Catlin from Washington State University’s Business School, together with her colleague Yitong Wang from Tsinghua University in Beijing wondered if this ‘licensing’ effect might also occur when it came to encouraging environmentally protective behavior. For example, in an attempt to make it easier to recycle paper could providing recycling facilities actually cause people to use more paper than they ordinarily would if recycling facilities weren’t available?

In order to test this idea two studies were designed. In the first study participants were told that they would be evaluating a new brand of scissors. Part of the evaluation process required them to rate how good the scissors were at cutting out shapes (such as triangles and squares) from a stack of approximately 200 sheets of plain, white paper. Half the participants tested the scissors in a room where there weren’t any recycling facilities, only a trash can. The other half completed the task in a room where recycling facilities were available in addition to a regular trash can. The participants were purposely not given any specific instructions about the sizes of the shapes or the amount of paper that they should use in the task. Instead they were simply told to dispose of any scraps in the receptacle(s) provided and then complete a ‘green attitude’ questionnaire that asked them about their beliefs and attitudes towards the environment.

The results were quite simply staggering. Participants who evaluated the pair of scissors when recycling facilities were available used nearly three times more paper than the group who didn’t have recycling facilities. Interestingly this increase in the use of resources occurred regardless of how positive the participants’ ‘green attitudes’ were as measured in the post study questionnaire.

So this first study demonstrated a clear case of licensing; the presence of paper recycling facilities caused people to use more not less paper. Now, one potential criticism of studies like these is that because they are conducted in a laboratory setting the results may not reflect what happens in the real world. So in order to test whether they could replicate their results Catlin and Wang transported their studies out of the university lab and set them up…..in a men’s restroom!

Before starting this new set of experiments they first collected data on the amount of paper hand towels used in the men’s restroom for a period of 15 days to work out the average amount of paper towels typically used each day. Once this had been done they then introduced a large recycling bin near the sinks with signs indicating that the restrooms were participating in a paper hand towel recycling program and that any used hand towels placed in the bin would be recycled. For the next 15 days they then simply measured the amount of paper hand towels used.

Consistent with their laboratory studies, paper towel usage increased after the introduction of the recycling bin by an average of 0.5 paper towels per person. At first glance this small increase doesn’t seem that big a deal however, given that the restroom was typically used over a 100 times a day the increase in usage was substantial. About 12,500 paper hand towels annually for this one restroom alone. The presence of recycling facilities led to an increase not a decrease in the use of resources. And in a big way!

So what’s going on? Well one possible explanation might be to do with guilt. If people experience a feeling of guilt when consuming and disposing of products they may feel that by recycling them they can reduce any negative feelings they experience associated with over consumption. Of course that subsequent reduction in negative feeling might now ‘license’ them to consume more because their over consumption will be mitigated by recycling.

Or perhaps the availability of the recycling option serves as a simple justification cue. Maybe people are saying to themselves “Hey if it can be recycled then it probably doesn’t matter if I use a little bit more.”

Regardless of the mechanism that is providing people with this ‘license’, one implication is immediately clear. When seeking to persuade people to behave in desirable ways, providing facilities that make it easy for people to do so, whilst vital, may not be enough to carry sway. Particularly in situations where there is little or no obvious cost to the user of the resource that is being consumed. This was certainly the case in the paper recycling studies and might be the case when it comes to influencing your colleagues and co-workers in the office too.

An example is in order. Imagine for a few moments that you have been ‘lucky’ enough to be volunteered as the new Green Champion in your office and you now have the not-so-enviable challenge of persuading your co-workers to use a little less paper, recycle the paper they do use and adopt some other environmentally friendly practices like turning out the lights when they leave the building. Imagine further that arrangements have been made for facilities such as recycling boxes to be strategically placed around the building and for energy efficient bulbs to be installed in the light fixtures. Knowing that these facilities, whilst essential, might also have the unintended consequence of licensing your colleagues to use more rather than fewer resources, you recognize the need to make some additional small steps to mitigate any potential licensing effects. So what might they be?

Well, the first might be to add a sign at recycling points and light switches, pointing out that whilst recycling is beneficial to the environment, using fewer resources in the first place is even more beneficial. Doing so would be consistent with emerging research that has shown that whilst the benefits of recycling are often highly salient to people, the cost of recycling is much less so.

Another potential step would be to take an insight from the consistency principle and highlight commitments that individuals may have previously made toward environmental protection. Better still you might seek small commitments from people prior to starting the program. Regular Inside Influence Report readers may recall the recent studies I wrote about in hotels where asking guests to sign a pledge when they checked into the hotel not only led to an increase in towel and linen reuse; it also caused guests to be more likely to turn off the light and TV when leaving their rooms. An example of a ‘positive spillover’ effect.

A well cited first order law of behavior change programs is to ‘make change easy for people’. These studies add a caveat. Providing facilities that make change easy for people, whilst crucial, won’t always be enough. The true detective of influence will also consider potential licensing or negative spillover effects and include steps to eliminate them within their strategies.

 

Discussion:

What examples can you recall of persuasion strategies that, at the time, seemed well considered only for an unintended consequence or negative spillover effect to occur?

 

How do you currently account for potential licensing effects or unintended consequences in your influence strategies?

 

Source:

Catlin, J., & Wang, Y. (2013). Recycling Gone Bad: When the Option to Recycle Increases Resource Consumption. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 23(1), 122–127.

PBS Quiz
Dr. Cialdini’s Books are Available Individually on Amazon.com.

Pre-Suasion

Influence

Influence

50 Scientifically Proven Ways to Be Persuasive

Small Big Changes Influence

Influence Science Practice Comic

Cialdini Certification
Readiness Assessment

Latest Blog Posts

  • Cialdini Asks: Richard Thaler
  • Cialdini Asks: Adam Grant
  • Cialdini Asks: Dan Ariely
  • Cialdini Asks: Amy Cuddy
  • Influenced or Influencer? Take This Quiz to Find Out.

Testimonials

"These were two days extremely well spent. This workshop is the perfect mix of theory and practice. Big Ideas and real world application."
Daniel Pink, Author of Drive
"…one of social psychology’s true pioneers."
Daniel Gilbert, Professor of Psychology, Harvard University, and author of Stumbling on Happiness
“Robert Cialdini is the Benjamin Franklin of research on influence–a keen observer of human nature, great writer, minter of pithy phrases, and clever experimenter who’s able to capture lightning in a jar.”
Chip Heath, Professor, Stanford Graduate School of Business
“We’ve had Dr. Cialdini speak to ERA three times. Because of his depth of knowledge and passion for relating the ethical business applications, he was the top rated speaker of at each of these events. He is a critical business asset.”
Ms. BRENDA W. CASSERLY, President and CEO, ERA Franchise Systems, Inc.
“This program will help executives make better decisions and use their influence wisely… Robert Cialdini has had a greater impact on my thinking on this topic than any other scientist… The best popular book that demonstrates six or eight ways in which the quirks of your own mind will frequently prove dysfunctional to your best interests is Cialdini’s Influence.”
CHARLES T. MUNGER, Vice Chairman, Berkshire Hathaway, Inc.
“Dr. Cialdini amazed our audience with his immense knowledge on the psychology of persuasion. His presentation style is relaxed, intense and ‘pleasantly confronting’. A brilliant mix! Over 350 managers could not get enough of Dr. Cialdini’s highly interesting lectures. After his last talk, he received a standing ovation, which is very rare in Holland. It was a sign of deep appreciation for his contribution to the success of the day.”
HANS JANSSEN, Denk Producties
“Dr. Cialdini’s program at the Training Leadership Summit was most impressive. His passion for translating science into ethical business actions gave these industry leaders powerful tools to use immediately. This program is a must for those serious about effective ethical influence.“
Julies Groshens, Nielsen Business Media
“Dr. Cialdini held our audience ‘spellbound’ for hours. His advice was both strategic and practical, and was geared perfectly for our audience from about 40 countries. His principles were put into practice by the delegates immediately.”
CATHY KERNEN, Global Director of Product PR, AstraZeneca Alderley Park, UK
“Dr. Robert Cialdini has played an integral role in the development of our high-potential leaders. His practical insights and real-world perspectives have challenged our executives to step back and reassess their global leadership and influence skills. He provides an important link in the development of our future leaders.”
GREGORY J. SMITH, PH.D., Administration & Finance Division, Organizational Development & HR Research, Bayer Corporation
“Dr. Robert Cialdini literally touched thousands of lives and you met all facets of our mission statement. He helped solidify an outstanding Day, and helped create the significant impact we were seeking for our diverse audience.”
MARK JONES, Main Platform Chair, Million Dollar Round Table
“This book is the de facto standard to learn the psychology of persuasion. If you don’t read it, I hope you enjoy pounding your head against the wall and throwing away marketing dollars.”
GUY KAWASAKI, CEO, Holy Kaw
“The Principles of Ethical Influence, as taught by Bob Cialdini, needs to be a part of every salesperson’s toolkit. What strikes me is not only the simplicity of his message but the power it provides in practice.”
R. CRAIG WILSON, Sr. Vice President, Sales Manager, Northern Trust
“Cialdini is the most brilliant student of influence and negotiation I’ve encountered. I can’t think of anyone I’d rather have advising me.”
TOM PETERS, The Tom Peters Group
"If the President had to have one advisor with him at all times my nomination would be Bob Cialdini, the world’s most practical social psychologist, and the master of "influence".
Richard Thaler, author of Nudge
"Dr. Cialdini is the great guru of social influence!"
Richard Thaler, author of Nudge
“Dr. Robert Cialdini is the seminal expert in the rapidly expanding field of influence and persuasion.”
www.goodreads.com
Cialdini, one of the greatest social thinkers of our time.
Adam Grant, Author of Give and Take
"Anybody writing about persuasion and influence today stands on Cialdini's shoulders."
Daniel Pink, author of To Sell is Human
"If the President had to have one advisor with him at all times my nomination would be Bob Cialdini, the world’s most practical social psychologist, and the master of "influence."
Richard Thaler, author of Nudge
“If you want to know how to influence people, just read Robert Cialdini’s classic book on the subject, INFLUENCE: The Psychology of Persuasion. It’s brilliant and effective, full of time-proven ideas.”
Steve Krug, Author of Don’t Make Me Think

Connect With Us

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on LinkedInFollow Us on YouTube

Headquarters Office

Tempe, AZ 85282
480.967.6070
© 2018 INFLUENCE AT WORK
All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy
Website Designed By VIEO Design