What Simple Change Can Affect Your Negotiations, Creativity and Even Dating Success?

Pinterest

By:  Steve Martin, CMCTSutton Place Hotel

In 1979, noted psychiatrist Dr. Alexander Schauss conducted a series of studies designed to measure the mental and physical strength of one hundred and fifty young men. Arriving at the laboratory, each man was invited into a small room where one of two cardboard signs was held up in front of them. After looking directly at the card for one minute they were invited to take part in a series of physical strength tests. Sometimes they were asked to raise their arms directly in front of their bodies while downward pressure was applied. On other occasions, a dynamometer test was used to give a more accurate measurement. Regardless of the test employed, it quickly became apparent that the cardboard signs each man was asked to gaze at first had a remarkable influence over their subsequent physical performance. There were no words on these cardboard signs. Nor were there images on them either. They differed only in color.

One was blue, the other pink.

It’s easy to dismiss the results of Schauss’ experiments as fluke. And given the weakening effect the pink card had on the men’s physical strength it’s even easier to label them a crude demonstration of a widely held stereotype. But to do so would be a mistake. In the thirty or so years since these experiments were conducted, behavioral scientists have developed increasingly sophisticated ways of studying how our environment shapes decisions and behaviors. Their results leave little room for doubt. While we’d like to think that our decisions are always the result of effortful cognition, the reality is somewhat different. Much of our behavior is driven by unconscious cues present in our environment. One of these cues is color, influencing a wide array of decisions and behaviors from how competitive or creative we are, to who we find attractive on dating sites and even if we’ll say ‘Yes’ to the offer of a second helping at next weekend’s dinner party.

taekwondoHow Red Might Have Helped Win Gold!

Even though her nominative connection to the color green didn’t hinder Jade Jones from winning a gold medal in the women’s taekwondo at the London 2012 Olympics, one wonders if her red outfit might have helped. A study by Russell Hill from Durham University and published in Nature suggests that it might well have. In reviewing the outcomes from four different Olympic combat sports where contestants were randomly assigned either red or blue outfits, Hill found that those who wore red won significantly more often than those in blue. Of course it is important to note that wearing red tipped the balance between winning and losing only in contests between individuals of similar ability. So no amount of red will make a poor performer a good one but it might make a good one a bit better. But why? A 2011 study published in the Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology provides a potential answer. Wearing red primes our perceptions of dominance. Conversely, viewing an opponent in red enhances our perceptions of them as a threat and in combat situations this can have a dual effect. By wearing red, we potentially enhance our dominance and because our opponent sees us wearing red we simultaneously reduce theirs.

Fortunately, most of us will rarely find ourselves in the sort of combative situation where it will be necessary to personally test if wearing red does indeed provide an edge. But there are some more commonly occurring situations where it could provide a distinct advantage.

Data analyzed from eBay auctions show that red backgrounds generally result in high bid jumps in online auctions compared to blue. A fact that might be worth remembering when you get around to clearing out your loft or garage. In fact, not only could red earn you more when selling those unwanted trinkets, it might also help when selling yourself.

Writing in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, psychologist Adam Pazda describes the seductive qualities of red. Men who saw photographs of women wearing a red top (compared to the same women in white or green) rated them as more attractive. But before planning that trip to the store know that red has its downsides too. Another study demonstrated how performance in an IQ test was impaired significantly after being exposed to the color.

Blue (or Green) Sky ThinkingPantone

 Of course, if you prefer to present yourself as a more intellectual type then blue or green might be a better choice. Both have been shown to enhance our thinking and creative performance.  They could help you at work too! To avoid a bloody bidding war in that next negotiation, maybe choose the pastel blue or green room to do your haggling rather than the bright red one.

Color can influence our behavior even further, in fact, it could possibly help you to shed a few pounds. People have a tendency to serve themselves more food when the color of the food matches the color of their plate. For example, white pasta sauce on a white plate.   But they serve themselves less when the food is on a plate of a contrasting color. Whether that means that you can encourage your kids to eat more vegetables simply by serving up broccoli and cabbage on a green plate remains to be seen though.

 

 

Discussion questions – Answer in the comments below:

  1. How can you use color to influence the behavior of others?
  2. Reflecting on the article above, what behaviors have been influenced by color in your business?

 

Sources:

Alter, A. (2013). Drunk Tank Pink: And other unexpected forces that shape how we think, feel, and behave. features a wonderful chapter on the influence of color and is highly recommended.

Elliot, A. J., Tracy, J. L., Pazda, A. D., & Beall, A. T. (2013). Red enhances women’s attractiveness to men: First evidence suggesting universality. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 49(1), 165-168.

Feltman, R., & Elliot, A. J. (2011). The influence of red on perceptions of relative dominance and threat in a competitive context. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 33(2), 308-314.

Hill, R. A., & Barton, R. A. (2005). Psychology: red enhances human performance in contests. Nature, 435(7040), 293-293.

Schauss, A. G. (1979). Tranquilizing effect of color reduces aggressive behavior and potential violence. Journal of Orthomolecular Psychiatry, 8(4), 218-221.

 

  • Ed

    Having just read this article, how important is the background colour of our webpage or logo when influencing customers subconscious decision making?

    • Alicia

      Very important… If your business is a restaurant, a red logo along with other “warm” colors is a great idea! Warm colors make people hungry (that’s why McDonalds is yellow and red – the most attractive “hungry” colors – and their logo is yellow on top of red, while their website is flooded with red, yellow and orange).
      If your business is a financial one of sorts (insurance, estate planning, finance help, etc.) you should use blues and purple – these colors make people feel safe and calm while at the same time suggesting you are creative.

  • Greg

    How much red? I go to Court. I am a guy. I can not wear a red suit. How about a red tie?

    • INFLUENCE AT WORK

      Red tie is a great idea.

  • John McDougall

    Red is also the color of stop signs, so it stands out strongly enough to be chosen for that. A blue stop sign lol? I suppose that would mean stop and think…:)? Sometimes red indicates stop or a warning but red cars, guitars and dresses go along with your great points.

  • Brian

    How often are these pop-psych experiments replicated with the intention to disprove the conclusions? I can tell you, after conducting many split tests – that many accepted “facts” about color don’t hold up in the real world. Red can increase or decrease buyer behaviors – it all depends on the context.

  • Guest

    Wasn’t there a study a while ago scoring recorded taekwondo matches where the red and blue colors could be switched by the computer? My recollection is that they were scored differently by the judges, with red performing better in otherwise identical recordings. This is an additional effect not mentioned in the article. It may not be that the combatants are influenced by the color but that the judges are. And in heavily judged, fast sports like Olympic combat sports, is the impact on the judge emotional or perceptual? Maybe one color provides a better contrast? Regardless, I will wear red to my next taekwondo match (so they won’t see me bleed).

Subscribe to the
Submit your email below:

vPOP Live & Online

From you’re the comfort of your home or office, explore the psychology behind what drives us as humans and teaches us how to ethically move others in our direction. Click here to register now.

Share Your Thoughts

Help us help others by leaving your comments, insights, and reviews on Amazon.com. This demonstration of “social proof” will benefit all.
Click below to read and leave current reviews on Amazon.com for:

Dr. Robert Cialdini’s Books


Twitter Updates

Login